Search This Blog

Thursday, October 10, 2024

My Thoughts on When to Make a Sequel

In an article that came out today, the head of Amazon Studios said that there might be a sequel to The Idea of You. While I loved the movie (check out my review here), I am vehemently against the idea. The movie told a complete story and does not need a sequel that I can see. Right now, any sequel would just seem to be a money grab, which generally end up being bad movies. You may ask why I am against a sequel here and for a sequel to Red, White, and Royal Blue, and that would be a valid question. I want to explain why I think the two are fundamentally different when it comes to sequel possibilities.

First off, as I said The Idea of You told a complete story. The story was about an older woman getting into a relationship with a younger man and the sexism and ageism involved when their relationship went public. They split and got together in the end. If they did a sequel, what would the story be? Would we rehash the same sexism and ageism? I don't see a good story that maintains the quality of the first movie. Sure, they might get married or something, but would that story be worthy of the first movie? I am not really seeing how. Also, you'd have to get over Solene's probable issues about getting married given how Daniel treated her.

As for RWRB, the way the story was told made it clear that more could come. First off, while it did tell the story of how Henry and Alex became a couple, it wasn't complete in the same way The Idea of You was. The ending was an end to a part of their story, not their complete story. Also, Casey has written more about their life after the book ended, so there is obviously more to tell there. The Idea of You, on the other hand, doesn't have a sequel and; having read the book and seen the movie; I don't see the story continuing. The ending to both (as I said above) was more definitive and felt like a period, not a comma or semicolon. There's also the fact that Casey is directly involved in writing the second movie and, given how protective she is of RWRB, I feel more secure knowing that (talked about it here).

Basically, I don't like the ideas of sequels being written unless the sequel can add to the first movie. This is different from movies where there are "sequels" that really have nothing to do with the original (the Cinderella Story movies spring to mind here), which are a whole other issue I won't deal with here. A sequel should organically continue the story that the first started. There should be some thread from the first movie that makes the sequel work. And in The Idea of You (as I said above) there is no such thread. Everything was wrapped up nice and neat and tidy. When a movie has to retcon a change or in some other way artificially produce a sequel, it inevitably is worse than the original and drags the original down with it. And that is something that I absolutely *DO NOT* want to happen to The Idea of You, it means entirely too much to me.

If the writers can somehow come up with a story that actually makes sense, I might watch the movie if it has Anne and Nick. But if it ends up being some sort of "sequel" (a la the Cinderella Story franchise) or if it ends up being a forced story, I won't watch and will pretend it doesn't exist.

I am begging Amazon to please not just make sequels to make sequels. Don't cheapen a deeply meaningful and beautiful movie as part of a cash grab. I know they are a company and motivated by money, but making a sequel to The Idea of You would be a massive mistake. 

Saturday, May 11, 2024

Some Thoughts About The Idea Of You

I've seen The Idea of You twice since it came out. Normally, I am not interested in cishet romances because they are a dime a dozen. Every time I turn around, I am running into a new one. They're nice, but they don't speak to me personally as a queer person. So, I tend to watch queer romances and I enjoy them a lot more.

My main exception to this rule is The Princess Diaries and The Princess Diaries 2 with Anne Hathaway. I see them as a trans story, which helps my enjoyment. Add to that the fact that I love Anne Hathaway and that these are (IMNSHO) the perfect romances, and I will gladly watch them. The other, more recent, exception is cishet romances with Nicholas Galitizine. I've watched every movie he's been in (still have 2 TV shows to watch at some point) and have enjoyed him in every one. There were one or two that I didn't like, but those weren't about him, they were about the story or the other actors. So when I heard there was a movie where these two were the romantic leads, I was instantly intrigued and decided to watch it.

I did read the book after I watched the movie and I have to say that I was not impressed. It wasn't a bad book, in fact it was in many respects a fairly standard romance (albeit with a non-traditional ending) with lots of fairly descriptive sex scenes. I was hoping that my love of Nicholas and Anne would translate to a love of the book, but that didn't happen at all. I finished the book and will probably never read it again. I will continue to watch the movie though, not as many times as Red, White, and Royal Blue, but a few times a year.

Ok, now that we've got the preliminaries out of the way, let's talk about what I loved about the movie. Anne and Nicholas have amazing chemistry. Watching the two of them together was absolutely electric. Bothe of them can communicate a lot with just a look and they've both mastered the art of tearing up on a moment's notice, so watching the two of them play off of each other was just fun. As Solene, Anne was in her best form showing shades of Mia with her awkwardness and her spine of steel that she can draw on. And as Hayes, Nicholas showed his mettle with the warmness and empathy of Henry while also showing some real playfulness and a desire to get what he wants.

I will say that the desire to get what he wants was a little offputting the first time they kissed in Solene's house. She said and indicated a certain level of discomfort with the kissing and he kept on pressing forward. I'm not going to say that it rose to eh level of assault, but it definitely made me uncomfortable because he wasn't respecting what she was saying until she physically pushed him away. I know this is a romantic trope, but it is one that I am not fond of and that makes me uncomfortable.

I appreciated how the movie showed the difficulties Solene was facing as a 40-year-old woman in a relationship with a 24-year-old guy. Watching the difficulties she was facing, I got really upset because of the complete and utter sexism and misogyny. If the situations were reversed and she was a 40-year-old man in a relationship with a 24-year-old woman, then people would be cheering him on and talking about how it showed how virile and desirable he is. But because Solene is a woman, most people act like this is the worst thing ever. To his credit, Hayes calls out this disparity when Solene brings in up in a fight when she is getting ready to leave France alone.  I will say that at the point where they have this fight, their relationship isn't public, so most of the issues are there because Solene knows how people will react and because Hayes' friends are not treating her very well. 

When they get back together and their relationship goes public, the misogyny that Solene feared shows itself in full force. The comments and headlines that we see are truly awful. They say that she is a bad mom because she's dating Hayes. People are coming up to her and telling her that their' little girls, who had a crush on Hayes were heartbroken. Sorry, but this is the stupidest thing to say. I mean, I'm sorry that your child who had a crush on a man was hurt, but to blame Solene for that is the most ridiculous thing ever. And her ex-husband was the absolute worst. He cheated on her, then divorced her and married the woman he cheated on her with. And he has the audacity to think that he has any right to talk with her about her entirely appropriate relationship with Hayes? He had one good point in that the whole thing was negatively impacting their daughter Izzy, but the way he just came at her and the way he acted as if he had any sort of leg to stand on was infuriating.

And Izzy is the reason the two of them broke up. Not that Izzy asked her mom to break up with Hayes, but all of the attention and awfulness was too much for her to handle. She had students at her school asking for a pic of Hayes' dick. And a guy she likes asked her to tell Solene that he turned 18 in a month. Yes, it may be typical high school stuff, but it was beyond awful too. So I can't blame Solene for stepping away from the relationship at that point. Yes, he made her happy and she made him happy, but the negative impacts on Izzy were too much for Solene to deal with.

I loved the fact that they changed the ending from what it was in the book. In the book, Solene and Hayes break up and remain broken up. In the movie, after she breaks up with him, he goes to her house where they kiss one last time and he asks her to reconsider her decision in 5 years after Izzy is out of college. She agrees, but insists that if either of them find something before then that they take it. So 5 years later, Hayes is now a solo act and visits her art gallery and they seem to be getting back together. I get that some people may prefer the books ending because it is a commentary on women being expected to give everything up for people around them. But I preferred the movie because it said that while women may be asked to (or need to) give something up now, it doesn't mean that they need to give it up forever. And it demonstrates that love is not something that can just be denied, it will wait as needed. Yes, I'm a sap. Deal with it.

In addition to both of their acting, I love Nicholas' voice. He has a gorgeous singing voice and the songs August Moon and Hayes Campbell sang were quite fun and enjoyable. I've had "Guard Down", "Taste", and "Dance Before We Walk" going through my head off and on since I saw the movie. Yeah, super catchy.

So that's it. I will be talking about the movie on my podcast Queerly Popular on a special episode on Thursday, June 27th. I'll go more in depth on the plot and expand on what I've written here. Check it out if you enjoy my thoughts.

Friday, May 10, 2024

Some Thoughts About the Red, White, and Royal Blue Sequel

 I woke up this morning to a tweet that there was going to be a sequel to Red, White, and Royal Blue. At first, I thought it was someone online playing a joke or doing wishful thinking, but as I looked briefly and found this article which confirmed that the sequel was in fact happening. Here is what we know for sure:

[1] Matthew Lopez and Casey McQuiston are writing the script.

[2] Nicholas Galitzine and Taylor Zakhar Perez are returning as Henry and Alex

And that's it. I have some thoughts and wanted to put them out there. First, I want to talk about a couple of plot possibilities. Then I want to look at some things I do or do not want to see in the sequel.

First, the plot. I really see two probable plots.

The first probable plot is that the movie follow Alex and Henry through their courtship and ends with their getting married. If they do this, they can incorporate the bonus chapter that Casey appended to the collector's edition of RWRB that came out in 2022. As a dramatic arc, they can have Henry and Alex learning how to navigate a public relationship when Alex wants to be in the public eye in order to get involved in politics and Henry very much does not want that. I think that would be fun to watch. They could have Henry abdicate, very much like he does in the bonus chapter, and have him run the queer youth shelters, again like he plans on doing in the book. It wouldn't be hard to have a brief bit of exposition that Percy signed over shelters for Henry to run shortly after the first movie.

The second probable plot is that Alex and Henry are already married and we get to watch them adjust to life as husbands. I find this one to be a bit less likely, because I think people would rise up in revolt if we don't get to see the FirstPrince wedding. Presumably, at this point, they would have learned how to live together and how to navigate their differences, so I'm not sure where the drama would come from here, unless they do some sort of artificially created drama, which would annoy me no end. I see this as the less likely possibility.

So now for things I do and do not want to see.

First thing that I have to say here is that I am a little apprehensive about doing a sequel. The fact that Casey and Matthew are writing it allay a lot of my fears, but I really don't want there to be a sequel just to have a sequel. I know Casey has said something similar in the past (at least about the book) and that FirstPrince is their baby, so the fact that they are involved in writing the sequel gives me hope. I really just want them to take the time to write a sequel worthy of the original and respectful of the fans. 

I do not want there to be artificially created drama like a love triangle or someone trying to get between them. That would just be annoying and stupid. The first movie revolved around Alex realizing he's bi and then he and Henry trying to figure out how to have a relationship as public figures. The drama all felt natural and unforced. If they throw in an old, dead trope like a love triangle or something, it will completely ruin their relationship. There has to be drama in order to have a movie, but the drama should center around the two of them trying to figure out how to live together and make their dreams work together.  We don't need soap opera or teen drama style storylines, just the everyday life of a power couple.

I want them to address the one question that the original never answered: did Miguel Ramos hack the emails or was he just notified about the hack? It is suggested that he was involved, but never answered. Again, this is something that could be addressed very quickly in some exposition.

I think they need to address what Henry does regarding his royal duties. We know that he does not like being in the public eye the way he has been and that he wants to be more of a private person. Given that and given Alex's stated desire to get involved in politics, I really see navigating this as the best possible plot for the sequel. It doesn't have to be (and should not be) a bunch of huge arguments, but rather a series of discussions about the boundaries of each of them and how they can work together without creating big issues between them. Again, nothing artificial or heightened, just normal relationship stuff that the two of them need to work out. Any heightened drama could be related to their wedding, which (given their stations and their families) could be quite amusing and fun. And it would be great to watch Uma Thurman and Stephen Fry butt heads.

Honestly, that's all I have right now. I expect the movie will be out in late 2025 at the earliest, but 2026 is more likely. It depends on how much has been written. There shouldn't need to be a ton of casting, so that should shorten up the timeframe somewhat. 

Saturday, August 19, 2023

My Ideas for a Red, White, and Royal Blue Limited Series

 If you've read what I've said so far about the Red, White, and Royal Blue film, you know that I think it would have been so much better if they had made an 8- to 10-episode limited series rather than a 2 hour movie. It would have given the characters more room to grow and develop and would have allowed them to be more faithful to the book in terms of plotlines and characters. I think that most of the big problems with the movie would have been solved with this change.

I suspect that the big reason they didn't make a limited series is it would probably be more expensive because you would have had to pay people for more work, it would have taken longer to write and record, etc. And I get that, but given the weaknesses present in the movie, it would have been worth it IMNSHO.

All that said, what I really want to do is to sketch out how I would pace out the episodes if a limited series were to be done. I am basing it off of the book which I haven't read in a bit, so I may be missing some incidents or forget which incidents were only in the movie. These won't be detailed, but hopefully enough to give people an idea of what would happen. I don't have any screen writing experience or training, so these may not be the best places to break in some respects. If you have alternate ideas, I would be very interested to hear them. 

Episode 1- Introduce all the characters, the wedding, end with the cake falling

Episode 2- Alex and Henry are forced to pretend to be friends, Alex visits England, the hospital

Episode 3- Alex and Henry start texting, Thanksgiving turkey, New Year's party, end with Henry kissing Alex

Episode 4- Alex trying to figure out what the kiss with Henry meant; Alex, Nora, and June invited to work on the presidential campaign; the British prime minister visits; Alex and Henry kiss in the Red Room and have sex in Alex's bedroom

Episode 5- Alex and Henry continue to meet and hook-up, smutty emails go back and forth, Luna announces he's Richard's VP pick, Alex and Henry meet at the DNC, end with Zahra finding Henry in Alex's room

Episode 6- Alex comes out to his mom and is fired from the campaign, the PowerPoint presentation, Alex and Henry visit Texas, end with Henry sneaking away from Texas

Episode 7- Alex tries to figure out what went wrong and flies to England to get Henry back, the museum, end with the emails being hacked

Episode 8- Nora works to find out who hacked the emails, Alex flies to London to be with Henry, Henry and his mother confront the monarch, President Claremont wins reelection, end with Henry and Alex visiting Alex's childhood home

I did leave out a few things: Nora and June acting as beards and Alex and Henry being photographed together kissing in a car being the big ones. I couldn't quite remember where they were in the book, but they could probably be thrown in where appropriate. And obviously there were a lot of smaller events (Alex visiting Luna in the Senate Office Building, Henry's interactions with the presidential campaign staff, etc.) that I didn't list but can be placed where appropriate. I was going for a more high-level overview of the series as a whole.

Anyhow, let me know if you have any thoughts. Enjoy!

Saturday, August 12, 2023

Some Thoughts about Red, White, & Royal Blue

 Ok, now that I've had a chance to get the issues with the differences between the book and movie forms of Red, White, & Royal Blue out of my system, I went back and rewatched the movie and discovered that I was able to really enjoy it a lot more than I did the first time. Since I wasn't so ensnared by the differences, I was really able to just enjoy the movie for what it was. This time, I felt all the feelings I was expecting to feel the first time.

Before I get started talking about the movie, I have to address some people online who were saying the the movie was just like the book. No, it absolutely was not. If you say that, you are either being dishonest or you didn't actually read the book. Yes, the core of the book (the love story between Henry and Alex) was there as where most of the major beats between them, but there was so much else that was changed. In interviews, Matthew Michael Lopez (the director and co-writer) said that he was ruthless about cutting out anything not directly related to the love story because he wanted to focus on that. So the movie kept the heart of the book, but missed a whole lot of other things.

So let's start off with the fact that, on the surface, Red, White, & Royal Blue is nothing revolutionary. It closely followed all of the rom-com tropes, especially of similar films that came out in the late 90s and early 2000s like Chasing Liberty or The Princess Diaries. That being said, looking only at the surface misses a hell of a lot. The reason that there are queer movies coming out in the last few years that closely resemble movies that came out years ago is, in part, because we couldn't make movies like this until recently. Because we weren't able to get movies like this widely released before relatively recently, we didn't get to see characters like ourselves meet and fall in love. We didn't get to see rom-coms like this where 2 queer characters go from friends-to-enemies. We didn't get this representation. And that is why this movie, however much it may have adhered to tropes and to well-worn paths. We are finally getting these things that cishet people have gotten for decades and take for granted. When Alex was talking to Henry about why he wanted to go into politics (to make a difference and to show other Latino kids that there was someone like them in power), it spoke to the importance of queer representation too. Seeing people who are like you and seeing them struggling to come out and be accepted shows you that it isn't just you. I also loved that the director was quite firm that this is a "queer love story" not a "gay love story". Even though Henry and Alex are both men, Alex clearly defines himself as being bi, not gay and we need to be sure that we do not erase that.

Once I was able to get past the differences between the book and the movie, I loved the movie. Yes, it was filled with tropes, but (as I've said before multiple times) I love a good romance and don't mind tropes. Watching Henry and Alex go from misunderstanding each other to a grudging friendship to falling in lust to falling in love was all sorts of fun. There were some hilarious lines from every main character and the chemistry between Taylor and Nick was absolutely perfect. Since the movie cut out everything that was not directly related to their love story, without the right actors, this movie would have fallen apart. And they got the right actors here.

Let's start with Alex. Taylor did a great job walking a fine line between being cocky and being obnoxious. Alex has self-confidence and assurance but not so much that he turns into an asshole. Alex is super extroverted and wears his feelings on his sleeve for the most part. There are times where he successfully hides things (generally from the reporter or when he is doing campaign/public stuff), but otherwise he tends to show what he is feeling. When he's in the hospital closet with Henry and explaining where his dislike comes from, it was cute. That was really the first crack in the wall between the two of them. Once Henry knew that his offhand comment about leaving hurt Alex, who felt like Henry could have helped him adjust to public life, the two relaxed a little around each other. And when Henry kissed him at the New Years' party, you could see him looking like a deer in the headlights. He knew what just happened, but he was blindsided and just trying to figure out what to do. And then there was his talk with Nora where he finally put the pieces together. She just laid it all out there for him and he was finally able to put those pieces together. I also loved seeing Alex take more of a direct role in his mom's campaign by going to Texas to implement his ideas. That was fun and gave us a chance to see Henry be sweet and supportive as Alex confused to some feelings that he didn't beling there.  

I'm going to skip to near the end, because most stuff in between was about them as a couple, and I want to talk about that separately. What I want to get to here is the outing of Alex and Henry. This was the one part I was dissatisfied with. In the book, there was a clear villain and explanation about why the emails were linked. We also got a chance to see the emails which had a bunch of great queer history and literary references as well as some great nicknames and spicy content. The emails in the movie didn't have that and were much fewer in number. Also, they never revealed who hacked their emails and why. It was insinuated that the reporter was somehow involved, but it was never outright stated. It just feels like they could have worked in a line somewhere to confirm who did hack the emails and their reasoning, which left the storyline just dangling there, which I did not like.

Having said all that, I have to focus on the Politico reporter. Having revealed that the first article came out about 2 and a half hours after the emails were leaked does strongly suggest that he was involved somehow. He saw Henry meet Alex in the hotel bar at the DNC, so he may have suspected something and gone on from there. The fact that he had made out with Alex in a hot tub and has approached him at least two other times to see if Alex wanted to meet again, suggests that he has feelings of some sort for Alex, making me think that he did what he did out of spite or because he felt spurned. And his reasoning for writing all the articles and why the hacking was ok was complete and total bullshit. Yes, Alex is a public figure because of his role in his mother's campaign. But when he said that there was "a pattern of obfuscation around this relationship and it is my job to explain and contextualize it", that was enough to drive me up the wall. That is clearly a justification for shitty behavior and it is one that people have used for years. The only obfuscation was 2 men, who were in love with each other and wanted to not tell the world about it. Why is that anyone else's business? Answer: IT'S NOT! This is all a part of the old idea that a lot of people seem to have where everyone who is queer owes it to the world to come out because otherwise they are lying. And to have this come from a queer journalist (ok, never identified, but the way he was chasing Alex shows he isn't straight) is particularly galling. Everyone, and I do mean everyone, deserves the right to come out when they are ready and to choose how they want to come out, even if they are a public figure. No one every has the right to out another person. EVER. EVER. EVER. Purposefully outing someone is the one thing I find unforgivable. I don't care what a person has done or how big of a public figure they are, everyone has the right to reveal their personal truths when they are ready. Alex's speech after he and Henry are outed was absolutely beautiful. He was clear about what should have happened and why respecting people's privacy is important.

So let's go to Henry now. He is caught in the middle of a Situation and doesn't see a way out until he and Alex fall in love. He is gay and he is a prince. He has a family telling him that he has to fit into an old, antiquated box that is circumscribed by tradition and ideas but he wants to be who he truly is. He wants to be with Alex but can't be with him openly because that just isn't done. So he has walls up and while he lets Alex in, the walls go back up once he realizes that his and Alex's feelings for each other are very serious. Nick did a masterful job at letting us into Henry's inner thoughts through his facial expressions and small mannerisms. If you watch his eyes before he starts to let his guard down, you can catch glimpses of his feelings, particularly his intense feelings for Alex. He lets annoyance and amusement show just a bit in his eyes when he is reacting to some of Alex's more outrageous lines and stunts early on. And at the New Years' party, you can see the hurt and disappointment cross his face when he sees Alex kissing girls when the clock hits midnight and when Alex is dancing with someone else. And when he let his guard down in Paris when he suggested that he and Alex make love, you saw the love and the passion that he had for Alex. That and the fight when Alex came to England to get him back were Henry at his most vulnerable and it was lovely to see. When the emails were leaked, you saw him just be devastated, particularly when he couldn't talk with Alex. And when he got the phone from Shaan to get the phone, you saw the trepidation and fear on his face about who it might be. When he heard Alex say "Baby?", you saw him visibly relax and go right back to being vulnerable and in love. The change was quite remarkable. And I loved it when he stood up to the King. It took him seeing that the King was wrong and seeing the crowds to really stiffen his spine, but he was resisting even before that. He just needed the public support to be really able to successfully resist what the King wanted.

As for them as a couple, it was such a lovely progression. When they kissed in the Red Room to hooking up in Alex's room to hooking up at the polo match to Paris, you got to see them go from an almost animalistic lust and need for sex to something much deeper. When we saw them kiss before Paris, it was just absolutely lust and not a whole lot else. They just went at each other with a ferocity that was really, really hot. And there wasn't a lot of foreplay, they went right from kissing to giving each other blowjobs. Nothing romantic, just wanting sex. There's nothing wrong with that, and it is a very logical first step to where they were headed. Once they spent more time together, the night in Paris was quite romantic. First, Henry suggesting that they make love and Alex gently teasing him for saying that and then admitting that he didn't know how to make love with another guy. And the joke from Henry about Alex being in good hands because Henry went to an English boarding school was quite funny, but didn't break the mood, which I really appreciated. Watching the two of them gently undress each other, slowly kiss each other, and then caress each other before having sex was so beautiful. It was just like a sex scene you might see in a straight romance, which I appreciated. And when Alex penetrated Henry, the look on Nick's race was pretty realistic, assuming you're someone who likes bottoming. You could tell from his face the moment Alex entered him because he got a look of wonder and enjoyment. The whole thing was romantic and just perfect.

One of the greatest scenes was in the hotel when Zahra caught Henry in the closet. Aside from the sheer and utter hilarity of finding a gay man in a closet, watching her realize what is going on and then trying to figure out how to deal with it was funny. She realized that they weren't going to stay apart, but she also needed to figure out how to not damage the presidential campaign. The commentary throughout the whole movie about the homophobia that runs rampant in society was not terribly subtle. If Henry or Alex had been a woman, the whole thing would have easily explained and no one would have blinked an eye. But the fact that they are both men was what caused the problem. And that is just ridiculous and is absolute homophobia. That's why they felt like they had to hide things and why the reporter was able to "justify" talking about their emails. If there wasn't rampant homophobia in society and they were able to just be who they are, there would have been no need for secrets.

I also loved all the scenes between Alex and his mom. Uma played a no-nonsense woman who was (for the most part) able to clearly delineate between her maternal duties and her official duties. The one time where things got a bit blurry was in connection to the Texas strategy Alex devised and that was because she wasn't told about it and Alex felt super passionate about the whole thing. But other than that, she was able to be supportive when Alex needed her. When Alex told her that he met someone and it could impact the campaign, she had a great line wondering if she was a Republican. Not fond of the assumption of straightness there, but I think it was understandable because Alex didn't seem to have really had any public indications that he had feeling for any men before this. When he said it was Henry, I loved that she sat for a minute as that statement hit her and then immediately got pizza so they could talk. I do wish we had gotten the PowerPoint presentation that was in the book and the line about not having had time was not the best explanation. I also loved that she went all mom and made sure he was being safe. It embarrassed Alex, but was totally cute.

Most everyone else had pretty minor roles. Alex's dad was supportive and didn't blink an eye when he found out Henry and Alex were together. Nora was supportive and helped Alex when he needed emotional support when trying to figure out Henry (a role she got because June was cut out of the movie). Bea filled a similar support role for Henry while his brother and grandfather were just homophobic and not at all supportive.

I loved all the lovely emotional scenes between Henry and Alex, particularly the scene in the museum. The scene preceding that, when they fought, showed Henry at his most vulnerable. He was really unsure about how to proceed given the fact that he had reached a fork in the road where his duties and his desires seemed to be at war with each other. What he needed was a new paradigm that would allow him to be in love with Alex while also being a prince. The museum scene was when Henry finally let all the walls fall down and let Alex completely in. When he was explaining how he loved to just disappear among the statues and how he wanted to dance with the man he loved while in the museum, you could see him absolutely just do everything he could to let Alex in. And when they danced? I cried happy tears because it was so beautiful.

I also kept cackling at the sexual innuendo between the two of them or the visual puns in the movie in general. When they were walking back into the dinner after making out in the Red Room, their conversation about henry being hard (and the shot of the extremely phallic Washington Monument) was hilarious. And then there was the scene in Paris where Henry revealed his full name and Alex said that he thought "Alex Gabriel Claremont-Diaz was a mouthful." Henry's response ("He is.") said completely deadpan and followed by a mischievous glance was absolutely hilarious. Their delivery of these lines just really helped them land.

I also loved the scene where Henry and Alex were talking on the phone when Alex had the turkey in his room. When we saw the two of them together on Alex's bed facing each other, it was really cute. I also adored the text exchanges, especially when you saw Henry appear on the screen to deliver his lines.

And I would be remiss to not talk about the very beginning which culminated in CakeGate. It was so different from the picture I had in my brain from reading the book, but that is ok. Watching an increasingly drunk Alex confronting an annoyed Henry, you would have known disaster was coming even if you knew almost nothing about the movie. And when the cake fell in slow motion and we got a look at all the individual faces? Priceless.

Now for a couple of things I would change. First, I would have preferred an 8 to 10-episode limited series because that would have given us the chance to have more characters from the book and would also have allowed all the other characters a bit more of a chance to develop. I do get that trying to turn a 421 page book into a 2-hour movie is impossible without making a ton of cuts is impossible, but I wonder if making the choice to do a 2-hour movie was the right choice. Second, as I said above, I would have preferred closure on the who question about who hacked the emails and why. Third, I so wanted to see the PowerPoint presentation about the geopolitical ramifications of dating a prince. That would have just been hilarious. And finally, there was a scene in the trailer of Alex and Henry in a kitchen eating that didn't make it into the movie. I hate it when studios do that. If a scene isn't in a movie, don't put it in the trailer or anything. I was looking for that scene and it just never showed and that annoyed me.

To sum up, I do really love this movie. For me to enjoy it, I needed to be able to separate it from the book, but once I was able to do so, I found that it was charming and absolutely lovely. There were a few things that annoyed me, but for the most part I loved it. Seen it twice already and plan to watch it at least once or twice a week for at least the next month or so.

Thursday, August 10, 2023

Some Thoughts About Differences Between the Red, White, and Royal Blue Movie and Book

I had the opportunity to see Red, White, & Royal Blue on Wednesday, August 9th at a theatre in DC. I've read the book several times and have been really excited to see the movie. While I enjoyed the movie, I do have some mixed feelings about it because there are *SIGNIFICANT* differences between the movie and the book. I know that anytime you make a book into a movie or TV show, there are going to be differences, but the magnitude and number of differences are definitely giving me some thoughts and feelings. I intend to watch the movie at least 2-3 more times in the next week or two, but I want to get my thoughts written down because that will help clear my thinking. So please bear with me because I'll be doing so using this post.

First, let's start by being completely clear that the movie was a lovely rom-com. I loved the characters, I loved the pace, the jokes, and everything else. If I hadn't read the book, I would be singing its praises to the highest heavens. However, because I read the book, there were things I was hoping to see that weren't in the movie. Characters and whole plotlines were removed, a plotline and a character were added, and some characters and plotlines were radically altered from the book.  I want to start by talking about the differences and then get into what I loved. I also want to say that I suspect that the changes were almost entirely due to time. The book is 421 pages, so trying to get that into a 2-hour movie is difficult. It seems that they cut out anything that was not directly related to the Alex/Henry romance, which does make sense to me. Personally, I would love to see it as an 8–10-episode limited series, which would allow us something much closer to the book.

[1] June and Rafael were not in the movie at all. I'm not sure if June was a huge loss, but Rafael did feel like a pretty big loss. His whole plot about being a double agent to expose Richards was excised. In fact, Richards was pretty much just a person running against President Claremont-Diaz, you heard of him, but you never got anything more. In the book Richards was a MAGA-type politician who had his campaign hack into and leak Alex and Henry's emails. While this leak did happen in the movie, they never revealed who did it, but did imply that a new character (a journalist Alex kissed [and maybe hooked up with?] a few times) might have been behind the leak. I can't say I was fond of that ambiguity. I would have preferred we learned who actually leaked them. The other reason I missed Rafael is that he was a mentor to Alex. I loved the scenes of him and Alex talking in his Senate office in the book.

[2] Alex's parents are still married in the movie. In the book, they are divorced, and this has led Alex to not be super into romance. While their being divorced wasn't vital to the book, I didn't see any reason to change it other than maybe saving money on a different set or something. And they also made Alex's dad a Congressman rather than a Senator. Again, not a earth shaking change, but it doesn't make a whole lot of sense as to why they made the change.

[3] Nora's part was severely curtailed. In the book, she is bisexual and had had a short-lived prior relationship with Alex. She got some of the stuff June did in the book when it came to supporting Alex, but she was such a minimal presence in the movie. She was also heavily involved in exposing that the Richards campaign leaked the emails in the book, so when that plot was cut, she lost a lot of stuff that she did.

[4] Henry's mom was absent from his life in both the book and the movie, but for entirely different reasons. In the book, she is depressed and not able to function well, only pulling herself out of the depression at the end of the book to stand up to the Queen and show that the people supported Henry. In the movie, she is working with a non-profit in Africa and is never around. While I appreciated that they had Henry stand up for himself in the movie, I missed having his mom there to help him out. And speaking of the Royal Family, Bea's character was also very much changed from the book. In the book, she has a substance use disorder as a result of her dad dying. In the movie, which she is barely in, she is just there to be a support for Henry.

[5] The new journalist (sorry, forgot his name) was an added character who seemed to be in there to be someone to be something of an antagonist but not be a villain. Alex mentions that he made out with him (naked!) in a hot tub and a couple of other times but wasn't really into him otherwise. It almost felt like the hacked and leaked emails were a spurned lover sort of thing, but they never stated that for sure, so I could be wrong.

[6] In the book, Alex didn't really seem to have a clue he was into guys. I seem to remember him kissing a guy or two, but nothing beyond that, so when Henry kissed him, it initiated a massive sexuality identity crisis spiral. In the movie, we see him figure it out pretty fast after talking with Nora once. I think it would have been more realistic for him to have needed more time to figure it out, but he just has a conversation and then acts like he has it all figured out. Coming out to his mom was hard, but that was more about him being afraid it would impact her campaign negatively than any fear that she would reject him.

[7] While Alex works for his mom's campaign in both the book and the movie, the circumstances are wildly different. In the book, he works in her campaign headquarters doing behind-the-scenes stuff (think it was some strategy, but don't remember offhand). In the movie, he goes to Texas to personally implement the memo he wrote about how the campaign can flip Texas blue. This is a change I definitely didn't mind. It showed Alex's interest in politics and laid the groundwork for good drama on election night when everything came down to Texas and how well his ideas worked.

[8] They cut down on the number of emails and all of the hilarious queer historical references which disappointed me. Those references were fun and cute. I was also disappointed that they didn't have the President do the slideshow presentation about the geopolitical risks of dating a Prince of England. I was really looking forward to that. I appreciated the emotional scene we got, but I found the whole slideshow thing funny and wanted to see it.

Like I said, there were a lot of differences between the book and the movie. There were enough that I need to go back a rewatch the movie with the idea that they are completely separate entities. I enjoyed the movie, I really did, but having this many differences and to have them be so huge is giving me conflicted feelings. Hopefully a rewatch or two will help me to sort out all my thoughts and feelings. I'll be doing a podcast episode (Queerly Popular) about the movie on Thursday, August 24th and will hopefully do a review of the movie as well.

Monday, October 4, 2021

Some Thoughts About Dear Evan Hansen

 I've seen Dear Evan Hansen twice and I have to say that I have been tremendously disappointed at the reaction to the movie. I really love the movie and thought it was absolutely wonderful. I've seen a few main criticisms, most of which strike me as a little ridiculous. I want to address those before getting to my thoughts.

The first (and most prominent) criticism is Ben Platt's age. He was 27 while this was being filmed, which is 10 years older than Evan. I don't care about this as much as other people, mainly because so many shows over the years have cast people in their mid to late twenties as teenagers in teen dramas. My personal issue is that the makeup department tried so hard to de-age him that it made it obvious that he was older than Evan. If they hadn't tried so hard, I don't think it would have been as obvious. That said, I also get the feeling that there are some people who want to find something to dislike about the movie or Ben and just glom onto this as an excuse.

Another criticism that I have seen is that someone would be belting out a song and people around them would ignore it (one example was Evan singing "Waving Through a Window"). This particular criticism was completely ridiculous because that is such a staple of musicals; particularly for a song like "Waving Through a Window" which is more of an internal monologue that Evan is having with himself. Another criticism akin to this was people complaining that characters would randomly burst into song. Both of those criticisms are what I would call bad faith criticisms of people who are looking for an excuse to dislike the movie.

I've never seen the musical on stage, but I have listened to the soundtrack, read the book, and (obviously) seen the movie. I have to say that I pretty much love all the songs equally whether or they are from the Broadway soundtrack or the movie. The only two songs where I prefer one or the other was "Sincerely Me" where I prefer the movie version and "You Will Be Found" where I prefer the Broadway version. I preferred the movie version of "Sincerely Me" because I think Colton Ryan's voice is better than Michael Faist's. As far as "You Will Be Found" goes, there is nothing in particular that I can point to that I like better, I just prefer it. As far as the new songs, I love both of them. I do wish that they had kept in "Disappear" and maybe "Good for You", but have to admit to being glad they cut "To Break in a Glove" and am agnostic about "Anybody Have a Map?".

Talking about changes, I was not overly fond of making Alana the founder of the Connor Project. It isn't so much about them expanding Alana (which I have no problem with), but I think it was better when Evan starts it himself. I also didn't get why they made a big deal about creating new characters, only to give them each 1 line in "You Will Be Found". That just struck me as a weird thing to do. I know changes will be made, but these were the changes I wasn't terribly fond of.

As for a more general criticism I've heard, I don't see Evan Hansen as an evil or bad person. Lots of people look at him and say that he is basically a con artist who is trying to take advantage of a family in grief. What people don't seem to get is that the originator of the lie wasn't Evan, it was Cynthia and Larry. They found the note Connor took from Evan in Connor's pocket and created a story that Evan and Connor were great friends. Evan tried to deny it and tell them otherwise, but they refused to listen. Then, as Evan was trying to leave, Cynthia grabbed his arm with the cast and saw Connor's name on it and became even more convinced that the story she and Larry created was true. And when they asked Evan to come over for dinner, he again tried to say otherwise, but they again wouldn't listen to him. And they fought in front of him, which is something that is guaranteed to make a person suffering from anxiety go into a mode where they will do anything to dissipate that anxiety and tension (I suffer from anxiety and do the same thing myself so often). He was trying to stop them from fighting and the only way that he could see to do that was to tell them a story they wanted to hear.

Don't get me wrong, I am not saying that Evan is blameless or anything, but I think that people need to not just blame him. We have to acknowledge that the blame for this situation needs to be spread around. Just blaming Evan easy, but it misses a lot of the other things that happened here. I also have to admit to some issues with Alana and Jared. Jared is just mean to Evan, who looks at him as a friend, which upsets me because there is a parallel in my life where I had someone I thought was a friend just totally betray me. As for Alana, I find it hard to believe that she didn't notice the inconsistencies in the emails, so I find it annoying that she only seemed to be good with him as long as he was doing what she wanted.

Sorry this is a little scattered, but I have had a lot of thoughts. Please go see this movie if you have a chance!

Wednesday, August 18, 2021

Deleted post

If you follow me closely, you will notice that a particular post has been deleted. It was brought to my attention that I had inadvertently put bad and hurtful misinformation in the post, so I deleted it and I will be taking time to educate myself about that issue.

Monday, December 16, 2019

Some thoughts about the Star Wars Prequels

This Friday marks the premiere of what is supposed to be the last Star Wars movie, The Rise of Skywalker.  As is my tradition, I am watching all of the movies this week before I go to see the new movie.  I wanted to record some thoughts I had about the prequel trilogy that I thought I had written down in the past, but apparently did not.  I do want to emphasize that my commentary is based solely on the movies and not on any books, particularly since the only books I have read are those that take place after Return of the Jedi.

I know that for a lot of people, the prequel trilogy is awful, but I have always been rather fond of the movies.  Granted, there are some things that are annoying (Jar Jar Binks being the prime example), but I find that the trilogy is an excellent reframing of the original trilogy.  In the original trilogy, the story is about Luke, the redemption of his father, and the discovery of his sister.  The prequel trilogy reframes the entire thing as an exploration of the rise, fall, and rerise of Anakin Skywalker and explains why he fell and how this same thing allowed him to redeem himself.

In The Phantom Menace, we are introduced to a very young Anakin Skywalker who is a slave on Tatooine and is freed by Qai Gon Jinn, the master of a very young Obi Wan Kenobi.  He is taken away from his mother to be trained by the Jedi, who are very reluctant to train someone as old as he is (and he is 8 or 9).  In fact, they refuse at first, but Qai Gon forces the issue and, after his death, allow Obi Wan Kenobi to train Anakin.  We are also introduced to Queen Amidala (aka Padme Naberrie), a women with whom Anakin is very clearly smitten.  In Attack of the Clones, we see Anakin after 10 years.  He and Obi Wan are charged with protecting the now-Senator Padme after an assassination attempt.  His feelings seem to have intensified over the last decade and it is clear that she starts to return the feelings after some initial reluctance, due (at least in part, presumably) to his age and due (at least in part as stated in the film) to his status as a Jedi Padawan (they vow to have no external attachments).  Despite all of this, they eventually get married.  In Revenge of the Sith, Anakin becomes obsessed with how to keep Padme from dying (as he has seen in a dream), particularly after his mother died in his arms in Attack of the Clones.  He is also shown to be close to Chancellor Palpatine, who has been a mentor and father figure when Anakin really hasn't had one.  Yes, Obi Wan has been his Jedi Master, but he has not been the father figure that Anakin never had growing up.  The relationship with Palpatine, along with the obsession over with protecting Padme, opens Anakin up to manipulation by Palpatine.  In addition, the Jedi Council has been so busy protecting their secrets and prerogatives that doubts about who they are and how good (or not) they are have been planted into Anakin's head and subsequently watered by Palpatine.

To take a step further back, we have to acknowledge that there are many cult-like aspects to the Jedi.  They insist on unquestioning obedience (questioning really got Qai Gon into trouble on many occasions) and generally only accept very young children for training.  Based on what we see, it seems that the reason they only accept young children is because young children have less to unlearn and are more malleable than older children.  By insisting that all Jedi cut themselves off from individual attachments, the Jedi make the children dependent solely on each other and the rest of the Jedi.  But if the Jedi are supposed to guard the Republic, this is not a good thing.  These qualities cut the Jedi off from the rest of the galaxy and promote a very navel gazing attitude.  We also see that they refuse to change, which leads them to further conflict, particularly with Anakin.  Granted, he is egotistical, but a certain amount of egotism is understandable.  He is a gifted fighter and pilot who is tremendously strong in the Force.  But rather than work with him, the Council is suspicious of him and this draws him even closer to Palpatine, who uses the flaws of the Jedi to break Anakin off from them.

In addition to the philosophical differences with the Jedi, Anakin also is obsessed with (as I said before) ensuring that he does not lose Padme the way he lost his mother.  He loves her so much that he wants to find a way to conquer death so she can live with him forever.  I will be the first to grant that this is more properly labelled obsession, but I think we also have to acknowledge that it is borne out of at least two traumatic acts.  First, when he was taken from his mother when he was 9 and then when he lost her when he was 19.  Add to that the number of comrades he had to have lost in the Clone Wars, and his obsession is somewhat understandable.  To push someone from love to obsession under such circumstances is not that hard.  So when Palpatine offers him a way to make sure that Padme will not die; particularly when coupled with his doubts about the Jedi; Anakin leaps at the opportunity and becomes Darth Vader.  He does go crazy (temporarily at least) and Force strangles Padme when he sees Obi Wan come off the ship she flew in to see him because he thinks she betrayed him.  This act ends up killing her and hardens his heart, which completes his turn to the Vader we see in A New Hope.

This same love is ultimately what saves him.  When he discovers that his children are still alive, he starts down a path to end the Emperor.  At first, he plots to overthrow the Emperor, but eventually he decides to save Luke by killing the Emperor when the Emperor is killing Luke by attacking him with Force lightning.  So love corrupted caused him to turn to the Dark Side and love also caused him to turn back to the Light Side.  This is the balance that Qai Gon mentioned in The Phantom Menace.  Not the triumph of Light or Dark, but the two being balanced with neither prevailing.  If Light prevails, it ossifies and becomes a rigid tradition for the sake of tradition.  If Dark prevails, it causes chaos and pure self-interest that ultimately destroys.  So the balance must be maintained (a similar idea exists in Babylon 5).

If you look at the prequels in this way, you can see that they are necessary because they show what happens when the Light rules unchecked.  So I would hope that the end of The Rise of Skywalker will help bring us back into balance with neither side prevailing because that is what is ultimately needed.  Not for Light to beat the Dark, but for Light and Dark to find a way to balance each other so that the galaxy is not tipped towards chaos nor ossified by order.

Sunday, March 25, 2018

Some Thoughts on Love, Simon

I just saw Love, Simon for the second time in theaters, which is really unusual for me.  Actually, the only time I have ever seen a movie more than once in theaters was when I saw Good Will Hunting three times in a weekend at a discount theater when I was in college.

Love, Simon (for those of you who do not know) is a movie based on a book.  It is a fairly standard teen romance movie, except for the fact that the main character is gay.  The movie revolves around Simon writing with another closeted gay kid at his school.  Simon is blackmailed by another student who has seen the emails.  Simon is forced to do some pretty mean things to his friends in order to stay in the closet because the guy who has his emails likes one of his friends.  Eventually the whole thing comes out and Simon's friends shun him because of what he did.  It ends with Simon and the other closeted kid ultimately getting together.  I won't reveal who the kid is, just in case you haven't seen the movie yet.

The reason I really love the movie is because it is so relatable.  If you are queer, you will know the terror that Simon feels when he is threatened with being outed.  Coming out of the closet is a terrifying and deeply personal process, and to have yourself prematurely outed is quite possibly the worst thing that can happen to someone who is not ready to come out yet.  Coming out is about you telling the world who you are on a deep level and to have that choice ripped out of your hands is traumatizing in a way that is very hard to explain.  I was lucky that I was able to come out on my own terms when I was ready, even if I was in my 20s at the time.  I can't imagine what it would be like to have someone take that choice away from me.  When Simon confronts the guy who outed him, he says that "Coming out is my thing and you took that away from me!" (or words close to that).  That is absolutely the case.  When people say that "Oh I knew that he/she was gay!" or "Oh, yeah, I knew it.", they are trivializing what it means to come out.  It is not about you and what you know or think you know, it's about the person coming out revealing who they are to you.  Even if you suspected, never say that.  Thank the person for coming out to you and revealing who they are.

Another part I loved about the movie is that they had a montage where the Simon's friends came out tot heir parents as heterosexual, which was in some of the trailers.  I loved that because we do live in a heteronormative world where people assume that you are heterosexual unless you specifically say otherwise.  Watching the parents reactions, especially the over the top black mother, was completely hilarious.  It was also very satisfying to see.

Something else that was relatable was watching Simon try and figure out his feelings and when he tried to flirt with other guys without actually flirting.  One of my favorite scenes was at the beginning of the movies (also in trailers) where Simon compliments a guy on his boots after surreptitiously watching him from his window.  I remember trying to covertly watch guys and see who I thought was hot.  I'm sure lots of straight guys (and girls) do it too, but they can be more open about it because heterosexual is the default in our world.

Then there was the scene where one of Simon's girl friends wanted to talk about hot guys with him after he came out to her (before the emails were released).  It was totally awkward and super funny.  He so did not know how to handle the whole situation, particularly because there was already a guy who he liked, even though the guy turned out to be straight.  Again, this is something I can totally relate to.  I remember guy watching with my sister after I came out.  It was a little awkward at first, but it was still lots of fun to do.

I also loved the way his parents handled everything.  His dad failed at first, trying to use awkward humour to deflect the moment, but Simon's mom was perfect.  She let Simon come to her in his own time and talk when he was ready.  I did love that Simon's dad redeemed himself and apologized for anything that he had done which made Simon feel uncomfortable about coming out earlier.  When he hugged Simon, I had flashbacks to the time I came out to my dad and he hugged me and just thanked me for telling him.  That was perfect.

Then there was the scene where Simon came out to his family.  n voice overs and emails with Blue (the other kid), he said that he hadn't come out because he didn't want things to change.  And that is the thing about coming out.  While you are still the same person (as Simon asserts), you are revealing something major about yourself that will invariably affect how people see you.  And that is very, very scary.

My only quibble with the movie is that Nick Robinson, who played Simon, is straight.  While not totally disqualifying, I think I would have preferred seeing a gay guy actually play the Simon in the movie.  Not a huge thing, but it would have been nice.

I really hope that this movie is the first movie of its kind.  Representation is important and having mainstream studios make a movie which shows the process of coming out and what it can be like to be a closeted person in the world we live in.  Please go see this movie because while it may not be a perfect movie or the ultimate, it is an honest representation of growing up queer.

Saturday, November 22, 2014

Mockingjay, Part 1

Welcome to the second to last movie based off of the Hunger Games books.  The journey has been long and arduous, but the Mockingjay continues on her quest for revenge.

Katniss Everdeen has been on quite the journey over the past few years.  She has gone from a girl who wanted to save her sister to the face of the rebellion against the Capitol.  And she has not emerged unscathed.  She is currently a profoundly damaged individual who has seen and lost more than anyone can reasonably expect to deal with.  She has been forced into a relationship she didn’t seek even though she does love the boy, she has seen friends and allies murdered, her home has been destroyed, the president has personally threatened her and her loved ones, and her allies have lied to and used her.  Anyone who can emerge from all of this undamaged has something wrong with them, and Katniss most definitely does not have anything wrong with her.

Jennifer Lawrence did a marvelous job showing the effects that the past two years have had on Katniss.  While retaining the core of strength that has helped Katniss survive, Jennifer also shows the vulnerability that Katniss has.  She cares so much about the people in her life and has such empathy for other people that she often has to wall herself away to maintain any semblance of sanity.  She was at her best in the scene in the hospital in District 8 when she said that she was the Mockingjay and would fight for everyone.  That particular scene was incredibly touching and very poignant.   Yet, just a few minutes later, she showed another side of Katniss, the fire and drive that has made her the enemy that President Snow so fears.  The ironic thing is that President Snow had a huge part in making her that enemy.  Like many tyrants, he laid the groundwork that created his ultimate enemy, the implacable foe who will do almost anything to stop him.

Josh Hutcherson continued to a wonderful job as Peeta Mellark.  While it was never specifically stated, I suspect that the Capitol threatened Katniss if he did not do what they wanted.  He toed the line to keep peace, which is in keeping with the Peeta we have seen in the earlier films, but when he saw Katniss in the ruins of District 12, that was enough to get him to rebel against the Capitol himself.  And in the final scenes where he attacked Katniss and where he was restrained in the bed, we saw the damage that has been done to him.  The closest thing this universe has to a white hat has been permanently damaged by what the Capitol has done to him.

The rest of the cast also did a great job.  Julianne Moore played President Coin with a quiet strength that conceals a dangerous enmity towards anyone who crosses her.  The late Phillip Seymour Hoffman showed Plutarch Heavensbee out of his comfort zone, but desperately trying to maintain control of the situation.  Liam Hemsworth gave us more depth to Gale Hawthorne in just a few scenes than we have gotten from the previous 2 movies together.  And Elizabeth Banks gave us a sartorially toned down Effie Trinket, without missing any of her personality.

Ever since they announced that the book would be split into two movies, a lot of people have bene complaining that it was only done for money.  While I have no doubt that was a part of the decision, I also want to note that had they tried to fit everything from the book into one movie, they would have had to cut out huge swaths of the story, which would have caused these same people to complain about that.  So pick whether you want to have more of the story from the book or only one movie.  Personally, I go with the former and am very glad that they chose that route.


As for the ending, I have read other reviews where people complained that it seemed sudden.  Had I been given a choice where to end the book, I would have chosen one of two spots: when they chose or when Katniss announced that she wanted to go to the Capitol to kill President Snow.  I think this ending, where you saw Peeta through a window framed by Katniss’ horrified face, made for the perfect ending to lead us to the final movie next year.

Sunday, May 11, 2014

Shelter

I can't believe that I've never written about the film Shelter.  The film is easily in my top 10 list (would put it at 6 or 7) and is one of those movies that I have a very hard time getting too much of.  If you want a synopsis of the film, click on the link above which does a good job at summarizing the film.

Plotwise, it is a fairly boiler plate film.  As one critic put it, "Shelter is a gay movie like other American gay movies. Boy meets boy. Boy comes out. Boys fight opposition. Opposition caves. If there's life beyond the closet, too few movies know it exists."  While this is harsh, it is also essentially true.  Most LGBT movies that I have seen end with a dramatic scene where a homophobic person is confronted and backs down.  But then again, a lot of romances and other movies end on a similar note, so this is not a conceit peculiar to the genre.

The reason I love this film is that you can really relate to the characters of Zach and Shaun.  Zach is a pretty normal guy who realizes that he has feelings for Shaun after Shaun kisses him.  In an interview, Trevor Wright (who plays Zach) said that Zach "didn’t know if he was gay or straight. He wasn’t 'born gay.' He had such a strong bond with this guy and was so intrigued by Shaun’s character that Zack just dove in for it and really wanted to explore the idea where he did find himself being truly attracted to this guy. That’s what I’m such a supporter in the community, doing the NOH8 campaigns, and talking to the fans."  I found it a very nice take on the character and the genre.  All too often, these sorts of films fall into major cliches and this movie managed to avoid a lot of those, so that was nice.

What I loved the most is that Zach really struggled with how he should handle the situation.  His sister didn't want her son (Cody) hanging out with Shaun because Shaun would be a bad influence, and this had a major effect on Zach because he always put his family before himself.  He declined an opportunity to go to art school (on a full scholarship!) to help his sister and nephew out.  He also was rather obviously trying to reconcile the fact that he was falling in love with his best friend's older brother, which could be potentially awkward.

Shaun, on the other hand, was always sure that he wanted Zach and was invariably supportive of Zach and his endeavors.  Unbeknownst to Zach, Shaun sent his portfolio to the art school again (and he was accepted again).  He also cared deeply for Cody and did what he could to help him out.  I also liked that he was not above using a verbal 2x4 on Zach when necessary.  That is always a good thing.

It's really hard to explain more because so much of my love for the movie stems from my personal experiences which I have already written about extensively in various places.  Overall, the movie is one with a big, thumping heart and a whole lot of charm.  If you haven't seen it, give it a shot.  If you like gay romances, I can practically guarantee that you'll love Shelter.

Saturday, May 3, 2014

Some thoughts on Amazing Spider-Man 2

Unlike my look at the first Amazing Spider-Man movie, this one is going to examine the story, so I will put in some spoiler space.  If you have not seen the movie and do not want to be spoiled, please do not read any further.  Otherwise, please continue....

S

P

O

I

L

E

R



S

P

A

C

E



F

O

R



T

H

O

S

E



W

H

O


H

A

V

E



N

O

T


S

E

E

N


I

T

Ok, that should be enough space.  To put it simply,  I was disappointed in this movie.  The first one was so awesome that I had high hopes for this movie.  Also, from the previews, I had certain expectations which were not really met at all.  Don't get me wrong, I did not hate the movie, but it did leave me feeling like I was missing something or like the movie was incomplete.

First, what I liked.  Andrew Garfield did another amazing job as Spider-Man.  He has obviously been working out because he has lost some of the skinny twinkishness that he had in the last film in favor of a little more buff body.  And, just like last time, his chemistry with Emma Stone (and with Dane DeHaan) is incredible.  Everything seemed so effortless where he was concerned.  Emma Stone played a bit more of a secondary role this time, but did a great job with what she had.  Dane DeHaan did a wonderful job as Harry Osborn, very different from James Franco who had more idealism and innocence to his character, whereas DeHaan played him as more bitter at his father and life.

My main problem with the movie is that it lacked focus.  There were 3 villains (Electro, Green Goblin, and Rhino) any of whom could have made wonderful villains on their own, but who suffered because there was too much going on to really develop any of them.  In fact, they were almost incidental to showing how bad Oscorp was and how they were responsible for Parker's parents death.  There seemed to be a lot of dangling plot threads that were just left hanging.  Also, in most of the previews, there was a scene where Harry told Peter that Oscorp had a file on him.  That was never in the movie.  If it had been there, I think it would have really added to the main story.

I really think the movie should have focused on one, maybe two, villains and that would have made it much better.  I did love both Jamie Foxx as Electro and Dane DeHaan as the Green Goblin, but the Green Goblin was only in a very small portion of the movie and seemed to mainly serve to kill Gwen Stacy.  Then there was the ending which ended in the middle of a fight.  That was just a weird choice.  Not awful, but definitely weird.

I suspect that they are setting things up for the next movie, and if that is so, I may change my mind about this one.  But as the movie stands now, I can only give it 3 stars at best.  Worth watching and fun, but definitely not making the most of the potential that they had.  I really hope that the third movie (assuming they make one) is better, because this one was a disappointment.

Friday, November 29, 2013

My top 5 favorite movies of all time....

At work the other day, we were talking about favorite movies and that got me thinking about my favorite movies of all time.  So, I decided to name my 5 favorite movies and explain why I love them each so much in order:

[1] Latter Days- My favorite movie is Latter Days, which is a movie written because the director (C. Jay Cox) was wondering what would happen if the person he is now could meet the person he was when he was younger.  The movie is about a Mormon missionary, Aaron (played by Steve Sandvoss), on a mission in California who meets Christian (played by Wes Ramsey), a young, gay party animal.  The two of them meet and fall in love, only to be caught hand have Aaron sent home in disgrace.  See, at first Christian has a bet that he can't fool around with one of the Mormon missionaries, but thanks to Aaron, Christian realizes that there is more to life than the next trick.  Aaron attempts suicide and is sent to be "rehabilitated" when he realizes (thanks to a music video) that Christian does love him.  So, he goes back to LA and reconnects with Aaron.  I know it sounds very after school specialish, but the movie is really one with heart and soul.  After I saw this movie, I knew how incredibly lucky I was to have family and friends who accepted me for who I am.  My favorite line is the last line of the movie, as the whole gang in LA sits down as a family and Aaron says: "Sometimes it all still feels like a mass of dots. But more and more these days, I feel like we're all connected. And it's beautiful... and funny... and good."

[2] To Save a Life- This is a movie about a popular guy in high school, Jake (played by Randy Wayne) who sees a former friend from middle school bring a gun to school and commit suicide.  This event sends him on a quest to find meaning to life.  He ends up in a church and connects with the youth pastor and other people there.  Gradually, he opens his circle to other kids who are unpopular until he discovers that his ex is pregnant and he has a major crisis of faith.  One of the unpopular kids is accused of a crime and Jake helps to vindicate him and then sets up a website in honor of his friend who committed suicide.  In the end, the guy tells Jake that he had been contemplating suicide until the day when Jake talked to him and made him a part of the group.  Again, maybe a little after school specialish, but the message is wonderful.  While you may never make a huge difference, as you go through life, you touch the lives of others in ways you may never know.  I also talk about the movie here.

[3] The Perks of Being a Wallflower- This movie is based off of a book by Steven Chbosky.  Logan Lerman plays Charlie, a troubled and introverted high school freshman who is befriended by Sam (Emma Watson) and Patrick (Ezra Miller), two seniors who make him a part of their group.  The movie shows how Charlie grows, lives, learns, and loves over the course of his freshman year.  The book is wonderful and since Steven Chbosky also wrote and directed the film, the big thumping heart of this awesome book really comes through.

[4] Defying Gravity- This was actually the first "gay" movie I ever saw and as such, it occupies a special spot in my heart.  The movie is about Griff (Daniel Chilson), a frat boy in a secret relationship with Pete (Don Handfield) who is attacked by some men shortly after he and Griff have a fight about whether or not they should reveal their relationship.  Griff is forced to grapple with his secret and eventually reveals his secret to his best friend.  He eventually discovers that the attackers were members of his own frat and after they are arrested, he moves into Pete's room.  This movie really helped me to discover who I was and made me think about what I wanted out of my life.

[5] The Amazing Spider-Man- This movie shouldn't need much explanation.  I know this is radically different from the other movies, but I do love superhero movies and I think this was, by far, the best Spider-Man movie I have seen.  I wrote about this already here, so I really won't say much in this post.

Some of my other favorite movies are (in no particular order): X-Men: First Class, A Walk to Remember, Shelter, and Rock Haven (talked about here).

Tuesday, January 22, 2013

On Looper *POTENTIAL SPOILERS*

My brother and I watched Looper on Sunday and loved it.  However, after I watched it, I was thinking about it (as is my wont) and it occurred to me that during the climax/resolution of the movie, there was a major logical plot hole that throws the whole ending into a state of doubt.  Of necessity, I am going to talk about the plot of the film and especially the climax/twist, so if you haven't seen it and don't want to be spoiled, turn back now.

S

P

O

I

L

E

R



S

P

A

C

E

The movie is about a "looper" named Joe.  A "looper" is someone living in 2044 who acts as an assassin for the mob from 2076 (I think).  Basically, the mob sends back people who are to be killed and the loopers kill them.  At some point, the future self of the looper is sent back to be killed as a part of what is called "closing the loop".  Joe fails to kill his future self (reasons to be explained later) and spends a good portion of the movie trying to rectify that failure.

Turns out that in the original timeline, Joe killed his future self and then years later met a woman and fell in love.  A mobster named the Rainmaker came into power and decided to close all of the loops.  His men captured Joe who was going to go quietly  His wife startled the henchmen and was accidentally shot and killed.  Once he got to the time travel facility, Joe freed himself, killed all of the men and went back in time in order to kill the Rainmaker as a kid to prevent his rise to power and thereby save his wife's life.

When old Joe came back, he initiated a new timeline by his actions.  Young Joe was injured and taken by a woman to a farm where she took care of him.  Young Joe met her son, a young boy named Cid.  Old Joe, meanwhile, went around killing 2 possible Rainmakers.  Turns out that Cid was the third possibility.

During the climax of the film, old Joe has Cid in his gunsights when Cid's mom steps in the way to allow Cid to escape.  Young Joe realizes that what old Joe is doing would cause Cid to become the Rainmaker and thereby cause the very event old Joe was trying to prevent.  So, young Joe killed himself to erase old Joe from the timeline and cause Cid to not become the Rainmaker.

Ok, that all makes sense on the surface.  However, there is a gaping hole in this logic.  In the first timeline, another event had to have occurred to cause Cid to become the Rainmaker.  We know this because at that point young Joe closed the loop.  Therefore, we can conclude that since the Rainmaker still came about, something else happened that led him to become the Rainmaker.  Therefore, Joe killing himself would not *NECESSARILY* prevent the rise of the Rainmaker.

I will grant that there are potential answers to the problem, however they are never addressed.  In fact, this plot hole is never mentioned.  Instead, the filmmakers seem to assume that the viewers will not notice the plot hole or think about it.  I think this bugs me mainly because of the fact that the rest of the story fills in major plot holes, but having this huge one at the climatic moment is enough to cause me to doubt the efficaciousness of Joe's sacrifice.

If anyone can show me that I am wrong, I would appreciate it.  My brother and I discussed this for about 30 minutes last night and couldn't see anyway to avoid this plot hole.  We could come up with possible solutions, but they all seemed to be a bit of a leap in logic, so we couldn't resolve the issue.

Thoughts?

Sunday, September 23, 2012

Some thoughts about Rock Haven

I watched the movie Rock Haven last night.  As with a lot of movies, it provoked many thoughts that I wanted to share.  So first, a plot summary.

Brady is a devout Christian who has moved with his mother from Kansas to Rock Haven, California.  Soon after arriving, he sees a boy and is instantly attracted to him.  He later discovers that the boy is Clifford, the son of his next door neighbor.  Clifford and Brady quickly become friends and hang out together.  Brady is obviously uncomfortable around girls, so Clifford teaches him some moves that may help him out.  During one such session, Clifford feels Brady's crotch and Brady jumps away and Clifford tease him that he is aroused.  Brady avoids Clifford for a while, but then starts hanging out with him again.  A little while later, Clifford kisses him and Brady flees.  He later confronts Clifford about the fact that he is gay and the two of them avoid each other.

In the meantime, Brady is being set up by his mother with Peggy, a Christian girl who realizes that Brady is gay.  When Brady and Clifford are on the outs, Peggy asks him if he has boy troubles which Brady angrily denies.  Eventually, Brady goes back to see Clifford and the two of them start kissing.  Brady flees, confused by what is happening to him and torn between his religious beliefs and his strong feelings.  He decides to go with his feelings and eventually sleeps with Clifford.

Brady's mom know something is wrong, but can't figure out what it is.  The night that Clifford and Brady sleep together, Brady had told her that he was being driven to a church sleepover by Peggy.  When he gets back the next day, she tells him that Peggy was in a car accident and confront him about what is happening.  He tells her that he is gay and she flips out and pressures him into breaking up with Clifford.  She also gets Brady to go to a camp to "fix" him.  Clifford is heartbroken and goes to join his dad in Barcelona, but not before before asking Brady to reconsider.  Brady says he can't, but then goes home to his mother and tells her that he won't go to the camp.  She insists that he is making the biggest mistake of his life and he says that he already did.  He tells her that he knows she won't agree with him, but asks for her love to which she responds that he is always her son.  He forgives her for what has happened that then hugs her as she weeps in her arms.  The movie ends with him saying that the pain never ended, but he has never been closer to God.

Ok, so now for my thoughts.  As a faithful reader of my blogs, you should know that this is a struggle I have lived with for a long time.  Even though I have more or less come to terms with everything, it is not a struggle that goes away.  But, eventually, it becomes much the same as losing a parent, something that is always there, but not as much of an issue.

What I mainly want to talk about are Christians and how they treat others.  In the movie, Brady quotes the normal verse from Leviticus about not lying with men as you lie with women, which is pretty much the standard Bible verse any conservative Christian is going to bring up when the topic of homosexuality comes up.  What I always find amazing is how few conservative Christians seem to look at the rest of the Bible.

For a long time now (since I was in college), whenever I read the Bible, I am struck at how it is infused with the notion of God's Love.  Read I Corinthians Chapter 13 (http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=1%20Corinthians+13&version=NIV) and see what St. Paul says about love.  Read the various parables that Jesus tells about loving neighbors (http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Luke%2010:25-37&version=NIV as one example).  Look at the Gospel of John Chapter 3 (http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=John%203:1-21&version=NIV).  Read what Jesus said about the Greatest Commandments (http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Matthew%2022:36-40&version=NIV).  Or look up one of the many other examples of the Bible talking about God's overwhelming love for us.  The Bible is a love story between us and God.  It is about His Love for us and how we should love one another.

What I find sad is that so many people who call themselves Christians ignore this basic duty.  Now, I do want to say that loving someone does not mean that you agree with everything they do and/or say.  I can disagree with you and still love you.  Many people confuse the two and think that disagreeing with something means you do not love them, therefore equating love with support of particular issues.  Sometimes, love is disagreeing when someone is doing something wrong.  However, how you express yourself shows your love (or lack thereof).  Talking about how "God hates fags!" or about how all homosexuals are condemned to Hell because they are homosexual is not love.

Which leads me to another point that Rock Haven illustrated beautifully.  Being homosexual is not a choice.  God created each and every one of us.  Being homosexual or heterosexual is a part of who each one of us is.  Therefore, your orientation is not sinful and is also beautiful.  God does not create mistakes.  He loves each of us and would not condemn us to Hell for something that is a part of how He made us.  Now, there is the issue of acting on those feelings, which is entirely different and within our control.  Everyone must choose how to live their own lives and then answer for those choices, one way or another.

As Christians, we are called to be love and to show that love to the world.  In doing so, we help others to see God as He is, Love incarnate.  So, go out and show love.  Be love.  Radiate love.

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

On why I like certain movies....

If you look at my DVD/Blu-Ray collection or the movies I watch, you'll notice that there are many romances or teen movies.  Alot of people wonder why I like movies like these.  After all, aren't they "formulaic", "boring", "predictable", or "not acted well"?  Watching a couple of movies like this yesterday, I felt moved (maybe inspired is a better term!) to explain why, so here it is.

I first want to acknowledge that these sorts of movies are formulaic and therefore predictable.  And I am totally cool with that.  The main reason I watch movies or TV is because I want to experience someone else's life (i.e. escapism [well, sort of]). Consequently, I honestly don't care about watching all original stories.  Sure, I like some movies like Inception that require immense amounts of thinking and interpreting, but for the most part, I want a movie that I can just relax and watch.  Teen movies and romances fill this little niche perfectly.

Also, I love that these movies aspire to bring forth the innocence in the watcher.  When we were children, we believed that true love existed if you looked, that good always triumphed over evil, and that things would turn out right if you worked and believed.  As adults, we lose this sense of innocence and wonder.  It can be a good thing to lose, but sometimes I know that I just want it back.  I still believe in true love, that there is one person out there somewhere for each of us.  But sometimes when the world is pressing down on you and everything looks like crap, I just need to be reminded of these feelings.  I need to be reminded that hope does exist, that love is out there, and that things can and do get better (somehow).

As I have mentioned before, I am a romantic (see above!).  I like sentimentality, I like watching someone fall in love, and I like watching people transform themselves into a better person because of love.  Most of my favorite romances are the romances where a bad boy (or girl) transforms themselves into a good person for the sake of love.  Pacey from Dawson's Creek, Nathan from One Tree Hill, and Landon from A Walk to Remember are three of my favorites, although I could mention several more.  There is a something special about believing the transformative power of love.  While I can't define it, I just know that believing in how love can transform you makes me feel better about myself and life.

So, I enjoy these movies.  Whether it is trying to escape my life into a movie about someone else, the uplifting transformative power of love, or just a sense of romance, I really enjoy them.

So there you have it.  :-)

Monday, August 27, 2012

Further Thoughts on Prayers for Bobby

After I wrote my post yesterday, I had some more thoughts related to the movie that I wanted to share.  You see, as I said yesterday, the movie is all about acceptance.  Both acceptance of yourself and acceptance by others.  If either one is missing, then problems can definitely commence.  In the movie, Bobby felt that he had no one he could talk to about his problems.  He saw the guy he liked with another guy and his mom wouldn't talk to him.  He felt that his immediate family didn't love him anymore and I am not sure why he didn't think about his cousin.  So he got trapped in a spiral of despair.

For some kids today, this is still the case.  People make fun of those who are different.  For many, if you do not fit into the gender roles dictated for you by society, you are a "fag", "dyke", "queer", etc.  Some families refuse to accept those who don't follow the dictates of their religion or ideas.  Couple this with the increasing personal isolation of the Internet age, and you have people who have trouble coping and finding their place, even as the world as a whole, grows increasingly accepting of those who are LGBT.

Now, I know this sounds like a PSA, and in a manner of speaking it is.  The thing about PSAs is that they are needed for a reason.  Right now, there are probably people who are contemplating suicide because of how they are treated by others.  I also know that my blog is not exactly wide read, but if I can help even one person, that is good.  I just wanted to call attention to the Trevor Hotline.

The Trevor Hotline is a hotline set up for LGBT youth and teens who feel like they have no one, kids like Bobby.  If you happen to be reading this and know of a teen who needs help, point them to the Project please.  No one should kill themselves because of who they are or because they feel unloved.  There is always someone out there for you, you just have to find them.

Go to: http://www.trevorproject.org or call 866-488-7386.  Please.  Pass this message along.  Save a life.  Because all life is sacred and all life deserves to be lived.

Thank you.

Sunday, August 26, 2012

Prayers for Bobby

I know that alot of my movie reviews have to do with movies about gays and lesbians and I know that sometime I might seem obsessed with the subject, but I also know that I can only write about that which touches me deeply and this topic always does.  Before I get to the part about me (because that is always part of any review), let's talk about the movie.

Prayers for Bobby is a movie about a mother's journey of acceptance in the early 1980s.  Sigourney Weaver plays Mary Griffith whose son Bobby (Ryan Kelley) is the perfect son.  Everyone loves him and he can seemingly do no wrong.  Then one day, he contemplates committing suicide because he knows he is gay and thinks his family won't accept him.  He tells his brother (Austin Nichols) who promises to say nothing, only to tell their mom and dad (Henry Czerny).  Mary is a fundamentalist Christian and tries to cure Bobby and pushes him to go out with girls.  Over time, their relationship becomes strained because Bobby realizes that he cannot change but lies to his mom because he craves her approval.  During a visit to his cousin in Portland, he meets a guy, David.  When he goes home, he tells his parents about him only to have his mom tell him that she has no gay son.  He leaves for Portland with his mother's condemnation ringing in his ears.  He ultimately commits suicide after seeing David hanging out with another man.  Mary struggles greatly with Bobby's suicide and after finding a bookmark for a church in Bobby's journal, she meets with the pastor of the inclusive church.  They have a couple of confrontations as she seeks answers and he encourages her to go to a PFLAG meeting.  She does, and while there, realizes that she always knew Bobby was gay.  When a proposition comes before her city council to recognize Gay Day and people are jeering at those who support the proposition, she tells her story.  The proposition loses, but this event helps her to reconnect with her family by pulling her out of her grief.  The film ends with the family going to a gay pride march and Mary finding a young man much like Bobby and hugging him to let him know that he is loved.

I know, it really is pretty much a boiler plate and formulaic drama.  But, that's ok.  I have read reviews of people who say that the movie was pretty much a waste and it should have explored the inner struggles more; but if you are gay, lesbian, bisexual, or transgendered, then you don't need the inner struggles explored.  While not everyone goes through the struggle to the degree that Bobby did, everyone I have ever met who is LGBT has gone through it.  The fear of not being loved.  The wondering if you will be accepted.  The times when you just want it all to end because it seems like too much.

Another complaint I have read was that the mother's questioning seems too simplistic.  But again, this questioning seemed very realistic to me.  When I came out to my mom, she asked me all the same questions.  She asked if I was sure, if she did something wrong, and if I wanted to be cured.  Ultimately, I knew that my mom loved and accepted me for who I am.  I am not saying that she would agree with all the choices I have made in my life, but she would still love me.  That I am sure of.

For me, I know that my struggle lies in wondering if I will ever find someone else to share my life with.  Regardless of how I may appear sometimes, I am a very, very shy person.  I do not like going out and that makes it very hard to meet people.  Also, I am fat and in much of the gay community, that is a sin of the highest degree.  A few years ago, I found a guy I really, really liked.  It took me almost 3 years to get myself to the point where I could ask him out.  By the time I did, I found out that he was moving to Florida because he met someone down there.  So once again, I find myself alone.  I want to meet someone.  I want to find a husband.  I want to have kids and a family.  I want to not be alone and pathetic.  But I always wonder and worry that I will be.

My other struggle lies in knowing who to tell.  You see, I work with kids as a tutor.  And while I know that I would never, ever hurt a kid, not everyone would think that.  There are people out there who would want me to not work with kids because I am gay and might molest them.  Never mind the idea that molesting or hurting a child in any way is so incredibly repugnant to me.  Children are meant to be loved and protected, not hurt or damaged.  One of my missions as a tutor is to show children that they are loved and accepted regardless of any mistakes they may make.

Anyways, I know I've said alot and I hope it was all comprehensible.  Seeing as this is a review, I want to end by saying that I think that everyone should see this movie.  Sentimental?  Yes.  But truthful and powerful all the same.

Love to all.